Zuares Education and Instructional Coaching
  • Home
  • Coaching
  • Resources
    • Academic Content
    • Brain Breaks
    • Content Planning
    • Formative Assessment
    • Math Standards >
      • Conceptual Understanding
      • Procedural Skill and Fluency
      • Application
    • Professional Learning
    • Science Standards
    • Technical Support >
      • Genesis
      • GoGuardian
      • Google
      • Phones
    • Thinking Prompts
  • Blog
  • Search

Blog

What You Don't Know

1/4/2018

Comments

 
​"What you don't know can't hurt you." - Adapted from Petit Palace (1576) by G. Pettie

In healthcare, data is key. Doctors, nurses, and EMTs refer to certain data as "vitals". These "vitals" include body temperature, heart rate, respiratory rate, blood pressure, among others. The data collected and tracked is so important, even minor mistakes can result in the death of a patient.

In advertising, data (sometimes referred to as "analytics"), plays a key role in the success or failure of a campaign. Advertisers often perform A/B testing, which involves the publishing of multiple versions of an ad and studying how one version performs over another. Advertisers track brand awareness and conversion rates, frequency and view through, among many other data points.

On the web, analytic tools are readily available to track information on how content is performing. This data includes information, such as hits, page views, impressions, bounce rates, and engagement. When these statistics are analyzed, decisions are made as to the viability of a particular strategy.

Statistics have even crossed over into the art world. An artist, by the name of Chris Jordan, demonstrated his work at a TED conference in 2008 (https://goo.gl/xwjx3b). Chris uses photography to tell the incredible stories behind seemingly mundane sets of data, such as the number of paper cups used in the US or the number of imprisoned Americans.

With so many industries weighing the success and failure of their mission on data tracking, why do so many educators act as if statistics can hurt them?

Instead of tracking key statistics on performance, we distort and obscure our data into bewildering figures called "grades." These "grades" are seldomly actionable and do little to reflect mastery of content or skills.

One example of confusing grading, is the practice of averaging. If a student receives a F on an early assignment and works extremely hard to master the assessed concept or skill, even if he or she earns an A on a later assignment, the student's final grade is a C. Is a C clearly representative of the student's efforts or current level of understanding?

And so what if a student gets a C? What does that really tell us about a learner? Given a traditional bell curve, wouldn't a normal distribution of scores typically fall in the C-D range, anyway? What would we say about a teacher if 68% of his or her students had a C or a D?

Another issue is that students quickly learn how to "game" the system. They strategically pick and choose what assignments they focus on, based on weight, and turn in just enough work to receive a decent grade. I'll withhold my thoughts on extra credit for a future post.

So what alternatives do we have? One alternative to traditional grading may be the practice of standards-based grading, where students demonstrate and track the level to which they understand a specific concept or skill. Teachers and students can develop rubrics, which help provide a framework for improvement. More reflective and actionable discussions can take place and learners can get a better understanding of their areas of growth and in which skills and concepts they excel.

In Catlin Tucker's article, "3 Problems with Traditional Grades" (https://goo.gl/YCNU37), Catlin lays out her three arguments against traditional grading and proposed an alternative to conventional grades, which aims to provide students with more agency over how they assess their learning.

Are there other examples of alternatives to traditional grading you have used with your students? Let's continue this conversation in the comments section below, or via Twitter @techcoachz. Please be sure to tag your tweet with #PembertonInnovates, so we can learn from one another.
Related Links:
​Chris Jordan: Turning powerful stats into art at TED2008 - https://goo.gl/xwjx3b
Catlin Tucker: "3 Problems with Traditional Grades" - https://goo.gl/YCNU37
Comments

    Subscribe

    RSS Feed

    Four Thought Friday Email Group

    Archives

    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    March 2018
    January 2018
    December 2016

    Topics

    All
    Achievement
    Amazon
    Animation
    Anxiety
    Arguments
    Asteroids
    Babies
    Bitcoin
    Black Hole
    Books
    Bugs
    Calm
    Cell Phones
    Climate
    Coaching
    Common
    Compassion
    Confidence
    Consciousness
    Courage
    Dancing
    Donuts
    Edpuzzle
    Emotions
    Evidence
    Exercise
    Expert
    Feelings
    First Day
    Focus
    Football
    Four Thought Friday
    Free Resource Friday
    Fun
    Games
    Google
    Grading
    Groundedness
    Hard Work
    Homework
    Humility
    Icebreaker
    Immortality
    Innovation
    Inspiration
    Instructional Coaching
    Leadership
    Lesson Planning
    Long Read
    Math
    Meditation
    Mindfulness
    Movement
    Music
    NAEP
    Organization
    Parking Tickets
    Passion
    Perseverance
    Phone
    Photography
    Plagiarism
    Plant-based
    PLN
    Podcast
    Professional Learning
    Protest
    PSA
    Purpose
    Relevance
    Research
    Sandy Hook
    Science
    Shared Experiences
    Shopping
    Skills
    Socratic
    Space
    Sportsmanship
    Squirrel
    Stress
    Summer
    Sustainability
    Sworkit
    Technology
    Testing
    TLAP
    Trello
    Tv Shows
    Twitter
    UFO
    Undone
    Universe

Schedule coaching | Four Thought Friday | Report a broken link
© 2019 Larry Zuares. All rights reserved.
  • Home
  • Coaching
  • Resources
    • Academic Content
    • Brain Breaks
    • Content Planning
    • Formative Assessment
    • Math Standards >
      • Conceptual Understanding
      • Procedural Skill and Fluency
      • Application
    • Professional Learning
    • Science Standards
    • Technical Support >
      • Genesis
      • GoGuardian
      • Google
      • Phones
    • Thinking Prompts
  • Blog
  • Search